Banner Default Image

Why Sales Hiring Feels Harder Than You Remember: The Cost of Going to Market with Outdated Assumptions

blog author

about 1 month ago

by Charles Noyce

Why Sales Hiring Feels Harder Than You Remember: The Cost of Going to Market with Outdated Assumptions

If you've recently returned to the sales hiring market after a period of stability, you may have noticed something unexpected. The role looks similar. The responsibilities haven't changed dramatically. Yet attracting the right calibre of candidates feels significantly harder than you remember.

It's a situation we see regularly with businesses that haven't needed to recruit for 12 to 24 months. Their sales teams have been stable, growth has been steady and hiring simply hasn't been a priority. Then a new opportunity arises, headcount is approved and the business re-enters the talent market.

The challenge is that the market they remember often no longer exists.

What Hiring Managers Need to Know

  • Sales hiring conditions can change significantly within 12–24 months.

  • Salary expectations, candidate priorities and talent availability evolve constantly.

  • Many hiring frustrations stem from outdated assumptions rather than a lack of quality candidates.

  • Market research and salary benchmarking should be completed before launching a recruitment campaign.

  • Understanding current hiring trends can improve candidate attraction and reduce time-to-hire.

The Hidden Risk of Returning to the Hiring Market

Recently, we spoke with a client looking to add a new sales professional as part of an expansion plan. Their existing team was performing well and employee retention had been strong. In fact, they hadn't needed to hire for around 18 months.

As we discussed the role, salary expectations and candidate availability, it became apparent that their understanding of the market was based on their previous hiring experience rather than current market conditions.

That's entirely understandable.

If hiring isn't a regular activity within your business, it's difficult to stay close to changes in candidate expectations, salary movements and competitor activity. Most hiring managers are focused on running their teams and delivering commercial results, not monitoring recruitment trends.

However, when organisations return to the market after a period of inactivity, this lack of visibility can create problems before the hiring process has even begun.

Sales Hiring Markets Move Faster Than Most Employers Realise

Businesses naturally keep a close eye on areas that directly impact revenue. They monitor competitors, customer behaviour, pricing strategies and industry developments.

The employment market deserves the same attention.

Just because a role existed at a certain salary level 18 months ago doesn't mean that same package remains competitive today.

Likewise, candidate motivations can shift considerably over relatively short periods.

Changes commonly occur in:

  • Base salary expectations

  • Commission structures

  • Hybrid and remote working preferences

  • Benefits packages

  • Career progression expectations

  • Job title conventions

  • Market availability of specialist sales talent

  • Reasons candidates choose to move employers

When businesses enter the market with assumptions based on historic conditions, they can find themselves struggling to generate the engagement they expected.

Why Employers Sometimes Feel Disappointed by the Candidate Market

One of the most common conversations we have with hiring managers starts with a familiar observation:

"We're just not seeing the calibre of candidates we expected."

While candidate quality can vary across markets, the issue is often more nuanced than that.

In many cases, the challenge isn't a lack of talent. It's a mismatch between what the market is looking for and what the role currently offers.

For example, employers may be advertising:

  • A salary that was competitive two years ago but is now below market expectations.

  • A job title that doesn't align with current industry standards.

  • A working arrangement that feels restrictive compared with competing opportunities.

  • A role proposition that focuses on company needs rather than candidate motivations.

None of these factors necessarily make the opportunity unattractive.

However, they can significantly reduce response rates from the strongest sales professionals in the market.

This often leads employers to conclude that the talent pool has weakened, when in reality the market has simply evolved.

The Importance of Research Before You Recruit

If you were undertaking a major business project, you would almost certainly begin with research.

You would seek to understand the market, evaluate available options and gather data before committing resources.

Recruitment should be approached in exactly the same way.

Before launching a hiring campaign, organisations should take time to understand:

  • Current salary benchmarks

  • Candidate availability within their region

  • Competitor hiring activity

  • Benefits and flexibility expectations

  • The attractiveness of their employee value proposition

  • The realism of their hiring expectations

This process doesn't necessarily mean increasing salaries or redesigning roles.

Often, it simply provides the information required to make better hiring decisions and avoid unnecessary delays.

How Market Intelligence Can Improve Hiring Outcomes

One of the most valuable outcomes of reviewing current market data is the ability to make informed adjustments before going to market.

We've seen employers improve hiring outcomes by:

  • Refining job titles to increase candidate engagement.

  • Adjusting salary ranges to better reflect market conditions.

  • Broadening geographic search parameters.

  • Offering greater flexibility around hybrid working.

  • Reconsidering non-essential experience requirements.

  • Providing clearer career progression opportunities.

These are often relatively small changes, but they can have a significant impact on both candidate quality and hiring speed.

The key is understanding where the market currently sits before making recruitment decisions.

Particularly Important for Employers Hiring in London and the South East

For businesses hiring sales professionals across London and the South East, staying informed on market conditions has become increasingly important.

Competition for experienced sales talent remains active across many sectors, while candidate expectations continue to evolve.

Employers that regularly benchmark their hiring strategy against market conditions tend to attract stronger candidate pipelines and experience fewer surprises during the recruitment process.

Those that rely on historic assumptions often find themselves asking why hiring feels more difficult than it did the last time they recruited.

Start with the Data

If it's been a year or more since your last sales hire, one of the most valuable things you can do before recruiting is refresh your understanding of the market.

Current salary trends, candidate priorities and hiring conditions may be very different from what you remember.

Before launching your next recruitment campaign, take time to review the latest market insights and benchmark your plans against current conditions.

Our latest Quarterly Sales Hiring Market Report provides an overview of hiring activity, candidate sentiment and market trends across the specialist sales sectors we support.

For hiring managers, business leaders and anyone responsible for building commercial teams, understanding the market before you recruit can save significant time, cost and frustration.

Key Takeaways

  • Sales hiring markets can change rapidly, even over relatively short periods.

  • Many hiring challenges are caused by outdated assumptions rather than a shortage of talent.

  • Salary benchmarking and market research should be completed before launching a recruitment campaign.

  • Candidate expectations continue to evolve across salary, flexibility and career development.

  • Current market intelligence helps employers attract stronger sales talent and make better hiring decisions.

Share this article